| 6 Mar 2025 |
 gdamjan | imho that's for units pid1 stores itself (for units created by systemd-run/dbus), probably doesn't read from there | 21:58:58 |
| gdamjan | perhaps nixos should put units in /usr instead of /etc | 21:59:29 |
 antifuchs | do we even have a /usr 😹 | 22:00:40 |
 Alyssa Ross | Yes | 22:02:00 |
| gdamjan | IIRC /usr/bin/env is required | 22:02:28 |
 Ramses 🇵🇸 | It's not a crazy idea to put them in /usr, imho, but we'll have to do considerable work to make that happen. We will need to generalise all the stuff used to set up /etc currently, and we'll lose some atomicity when switching generations | 22:25:21 |
| Alyssa Ross | We could just install a symlink to a /etc (or /run/current-system) subdirectory in /usr | 22:26:29 |
 eliasp | gdamjan the thing is, it still evaluates the unit in transient, but apparently doesn't apply all directives... Documentation= works, ExecStart= doesn't
nonetheless, I agree that it would be nice to have them all in /usr instead of /etc, but yeah - a looot of work | 23:20:04 |
| eliasp | but while we're at it - anyone feels like picking up my systemd-localectl-archive-path branch (fix for #267101 and successor of #375062)
I don't have time for it right now and I can't figure out, why my patch shows now effect… | 23:22:06 |
| eliasp | but while we're at it - anyone feels like picking up my systemd-localectl-archive-path branch (fix for #267101 and successor of #375062)?
I don't have time for it right now and I can't figure out, why my patch shows now effect… | 23:22:13 |
| eliasp | but while we're at it - anyone feels like picking up my systemd-localectl-archive-path branch (fix for #267101 and successor of #375062)?
I don't have time for it right now and I can't figure out, why my patch shows no effect… | 23:22:24 |
| 7 Mar 2025 |
 Arian | I think the fix here is that we shouldn't put nix generated config in /etc we should put it in /nix/store and extend SYSTEMD_UNIT_PATH | 07:47:07 |
| Arian | That's my take | 07:47:31 |
| Alyssa Ross | libeconf has the same weird ordering and is being pushed pretty hard for projects to implement the UAPI Group's Configuration Files Specification, so if we continue avoiding /usr for config files it won't just be systemd we need to patch. | 08:04:37 |
 K900 | Does it mean /usr as in /usr | 08:05:42 |
| K900 | Or /usr as in $prefix | 08:05:48 |
| Arian | Well systemd's build system already doesn't respect $prefix . We patch that in | 08:06:11 |
| Arian | For e.g. udev and tmpfiles | 08:06:20 |
| Arian | They hardcode /usr in the c code | 08:06:38 |
| Arian | :( | 08:06:39 |
| Arian | In a lot of places | 08:06:42 |
| Arian | * Well systemd's build already doesn't respect $prefix . We patch that in | 08:06:59 |
| Arian | But what I mean is. When we run tools that support pointing to config through a cli argument we should use that | 08:08:11 |
| Arian | Instead of /etc | 08:08:16 |
| Arian | Run tmpfiles with --definitions ${blah} | 08:08:35 |
| Arian | Run systemd with --units-dir ${blah} | 08:08:50 |
| Arian | Ignore all this silly FHS stuff | 08:09:01 |
| Arian | Pointless waste of time for us | 08:09:21 |
| Arian | Things should be in the nix store except for some really rare exceptions | 08:09:47 |
| Arian | And that approach doesn't require patches | 08:10:55 |
