!LemuOOvbWqRXodtSsw:nixos.org

NixOS Reproducible Builds

544 Members
Report: https://reproducible.nixos.org Project progress: https://github.com/orgs/NixOS/projects/30125 Servers

Load older messages


SenderMessageTime
1 Dec 2021
@baloo_:matrix.orgbalooall 3 are dependent on builder's environment14:18:18
@baloo_:matrix.orgbalooI have a patch that selects the configuration settings where to filter out default values15:05:09
@baloo_:matrix.orgbaloo(and I'm removing all 3 of those options)15:05:19
@baloo_:matrix.orgbaloothere might be a better approach but I don't know15:05:48
@baloo_:matrix.orgbaloohttps://github.com/NixOS/nix/pull/5702/files?w=115:13:02
@tomberek:matrix.orgtombereklooking...16:03:03
4 Dec 2021
@immae:immae.euimmae left the room.10:59:16
5 Dec 2021
@teevorian:matrix.orgsvhe joined the room.03:47:04
7 Dec 2021
@cypher25519:matrix.orgcypher joined the room.22:54:24
8 Dec 2021
@arcz:matrix.orgarcz joined the room.16:22:53
@arcz:matrix.orgarczhey, I'm wondering if r13y is really verifying that NixOS image is reproducible. It seems that only the direct dependencies are rebuilt, not the whole tree down to some root bootstrap package, is that right? Is it possible to rebuild the whole tree, is it even worth it?16:33:55
@raboof:matrix.orgraboof
In reply to @arcz:matrix.org
hey, I'm wondering if r13y is really verifying that NixOS image is reproducible. It seems that only the direct dependencies are rebuilt, not the whole tree down to some root bootstrap package, is that right? Is it possible to rebuild the whole tree, is it even worth it?
https://r13y.com/ doesn't check everything. One thing you could do is take an 'old' image, install Nix, download nixpkgs, disable cachix, and build the image. I have found a couple of issues like that in the past (e.g. around the way we used mksquashfs IIRC), but I'm not aware of any remaining.
16:58:04
@arcz:matrix.orgarcz raboof: not sure if I understood you correctly, so you tried to build everything from source and it reproduced, but it's not automated in r13y? 17:09:50
9 Dec 2021
@raboof:matrix.orgraboof
In reply to @arcz:matrix.org
raboof: not sure if I understood you correctly, so you tried to build everything from source and it reproduced, but it's not automated in r13y?
I don't think I ever got around to actually successfully reproducing end-to-end, but AFAIK we did fix all the problems I found when I tried it the last time. Indeed r13y does not automate everything (but quite a lot).
08:18:35
10 Dec 2021
@siraben:matrix.orgsiraben
In reply to @raboof:matrix.org
https://r13y.com/ doesn't check everything. One thing you could do is take an 'old' image, install Nix, download nixpkgs, disable cachix, and build the image. I have found a couple of issues like that in the past (e.g. around the way we used mksquashfs IIRC), but I'm not aware of any remaining.
A similar situation I ran into was when I was testing out CA, several URLs were broken because our caching kept it longer than upstream did
00:56:10
12 Dec 2021
@srid:matrix.orgsrid (on hiatus) changed their display name from Moved to @srid:one.ems.host to Sridhar Ratnakumar.23:54:09
@srid:matrix.orgsrid (on hiatus) set a profile picture.23:54:16
14 Dec 2021
@baloo_:matrix.orgbaloo https://github.com/NixOS/nix/pull/5702 merged \o/ now we just need the backport and a release 11:15:47
@baloo_:matrix.orgbalooand back to 100%11:15:51
@rick:matrix.ciphernetics.nlRick (Mindavi)Most of the gnome_iso issues seem to be related to haskell19:27:53
@tomberek:matrix.orgtomberek
In reply to @rick:matrix.ciphernetics.nl
Most of the gnome_iso issues seem to be related to haskell
Typical, people not caring about purity.....err...... wait a sec!!
21:48:42
15 Dec 2021
@muhammadrahim:matrix.orgMuhammad Rahim joined the room.16:58:26
16 Dec 2021
@kenmacd:matrix.org@kenmacd:matrix.org joined the room.03:22:35
@maximsmol:matrix.org@maximsmol:matrix.org joined the room.21:42:14
19 Dec 2021
@atemu12:matrix.orgatemu12https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/issues/15134717:22:29
@rick:matrix.ciphernetics.nlRick (Mindavi)Thanks for opening an issue about it17:24:03
@artturin:matrix.orgArtturinhttps://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/pull/15135619:10:52
20 Dec 2021
@ercao:matrix.orgercao joined the room.17:21:25
@baloo_:matrix.orgbalooNix2.5.1 merged in master. So the man build for nix should be fixed soon21:06:31
@rick:matrix.ciphernetics.nlRick (Mindavi)I made an issue about an interaction between separateDebugInfo and ca-derivations: https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/issues/15147522:53:33

Show newer messages


Back to Room ListRoom Version: 6