| 22 Oct 2022 |
 k0kada (he/him) | Well, yeah | 15:43:09 |
| k0kada (he/him) | Maybe if we could ask upstream to be more careful | 15:43:19 |
| k0kada (he/him) | What is actually mutable, what it is not | 15:43:34 |
| k0kada (he/him) | Maybe having a separate file too defining those things so we don't need to fix our patches on every change | 15:43:53 |
| k0kada (he/him) | Also, the profile changes make zero sense for us, I would like to disable it if possible | 15:44:58 |
 mei 🌒& | searching for existing issues | 15:47:46 |
| * mei 🌒& is now reading upstream#1708 | 15:52:21 |
| k0kada (he/him) | In reply to @ckie:ckie.dev
like our impl of straight.el and whatnot is quite inaccurate but yeah If we really think about it, doom-emacs doesn't make too much sense when you have Nix
You can literally have all the advantages of straight.el without dealing with the complexity of it | 16:00:51 |
| k0kada (he/him) | However, rewriting doom-emacs in Nix also doesn't seem like a good idea imo | 16:01:15 |
| mei 🌒& | mm yes, we have a balance to deal with | 16:02:09 |
| k0kada (he/him) | In reply to @ckie:ckie.dev
thoughts on soft fork of the doom repo? Maybe a hard fork could work, where we drop everything related to straight.el and rebuild using the Emacs withPackages | 16:02:16 |
| k0kada (he/him) | But them it is our own lol | 16:02:36 |
| mei 🌒& | yeah | 16:02:39 |
| mei 🌒& | In reply to @ckie:ckie.dev
mm yes, we have a balance to deal with need to find a way where we can leech off of the main project for most of the effort | 16:03:01 |
| mei 🌒& | we can draw in the last 20% or whatnot | 16:03:11 |
| k0kada (he/him) | In reply to @ckie:ckie.dev
need to find a way where we can leech off of the main project for most of the effort Maybe we could convince upstream to have a way to skip straight.el entirely | 16:04:10 |
| k0kada (he/him) | Something like "just load the packages from this directory" | 16:04:21 |
| k0kada (he/him) | Also convince them to use JSON to declare the packages, we could consume it and drop nix-straight.el entirely | 16:05:13 |
| mei 🌒& | it's more intertwined than that | 16:06:51 |
| mei 🌒& | straight.el also decides the package versions | 16:07:00 |
| mei 🌒& | but they can also be locked from within doom | 16:07:15 |
| k0kada (he/him) | In reply to @ckie:ckie.dev
it's more intertwined than that Yeah, what I meant was more like if upstream maybe could generate its lock for their versions or something after each update | 16:08:26 |
| mei 🌒& | as in doom sync? | 16:08:53 |
| k0kada (he/him) | Yeah | 16:09:02 |
| k0kada (he/him) | And publish in the repo in a format that we could consume | 16:09:21 |
| mei 🌒& | "the repo"? doom sync is runtime for imperative uesrs | 16:10:19 |
| mei 🌒& | * "the repo"? doom sync is runtime for imperative users | 16:10:21 |
| mei 🌒& | you can have package! in your config | 16:10:41 |
| k0kada (he/him) | In reply to @ckie:ckie.dev
you can have package! in your config I know, but only for the things that upstream has a ping | 16:11:20 |
| mei 🌒& | ooh now i'm curious, wanna swap configs? | 16:11:21 |
