| 8 Oct 2024 |
 Tristan Ross | In reply to @emilazy:matrix.org
https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/issues/339153 seems wrong. it implies that breaking changes are never forbidden on master How does it seem wrong? I copied from the release wiki. | 13:52:21 |
 Lily Foster | In reply to @emilazy:matrix.org
https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/issues/339153 seems wrong. it implies that breaking changes are never forbidden on master pretty sure the intent is to restrict at the same time as staging is, as was done in 24.05 https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/issues/303285. though admittedly release wiki nor rfc85 ever included that | 14:11:28 |
 emily | it implies that breaking changes are only forbidden on staging branches | 14:11:53 |
| emily | which the 24.05 issue differed on | 14:12:09 |
| emily | In reply to @lily:lily.flowers
pretty sure the intent is to restrict at the same time as staging is, as was done in 24.05 https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/issues/303285. though admittedly release wiki nor rfc85 ever included that so it's a chronic problem, ok đź« | 14:12:32 |
 Randy Eckenrode | Given the Darwin stuff can’t go to master, what the policy is for master doesn’t pertinent. My only concern is getting the Darwin stuff into 24.11. | 14:14:35 |
| Randy Eckenrode | * Given the Darwin stuff can’t go to master, what the policy is for master doesn’t seem pertinent. My only concern is getting the Darwin stuff into 24.11. | 14:14:46 |
| Lily Foster | looke like @hexa first started to change it in 22.11 https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/issues/193585 but it was not included in the post-release fixup https://github.com/NixOS/release-wiki/pull/60 | 14:15:39 |
| emily | In reply to @reckenrode:matrix.org
Given the Darwin stuff can’t go to master, what the policy is for master doesn’t seem pertinent. My only concern is getting the Darwin stuff into 24.11. I cared about master for my own stuff | 14:43:56 |
| emily | which is why the schedule confused me | 14:44:18 |
| Tristan Ross | In reply to @reckenrode:matrix.org
Given the Darwin stuff can’t go to master, what the policy is for master doesn’t seem pertinent. My only concern is getting the Darwin stuff into 24.11. How far do you think we are from being able to merge it? | 17:59:47 |
| emily | a few days | 18:05:40 |
| emily | it's just pending review from two other people who have started going through it already | 18:05:58 |
| emily | the follow-up PRs are mostly ready | 18:06:09 |
| emily | it'll definitely make the next staging-next cycle, which at this rate might not even start before the 11th | 18:06:57 |
| Tristan Ross | Ok, I think we're good then to get it into 24.11 | 18:25:06 |
 vcunat | I wonder about staging-next-24.05 as it's been quite some time, too. | 18:25:09 |
| vcunat | * I wonder about staging-next-24.05 as it's been quite some time, too. (4 weeks) | 18:25:33 |
| Tristan Ross | We can probably squeeze in 1 last staging-next for 24.05? | 18:25:38 |
| vcunat | 1 last seems way too little to me. Given that we promise support until the end of the year? | 18:26:16 |
| Tristan Ross | Oh | 18:26:54 |
| Tristan Ross | Then we probably can get like 4 or 5 staging-nexts for 24.05? | 18:27:35 |
| emily | In reply to @vcunat:matrix.org
I wonder about staging-next-24.05 as it's been quite some time, too. (4 weeks) I worry that if we do 24.05 next, the Darwin rework cycle becomes the last cycle before release? | 18:33:29 |
| emily | which would be pretty not good | 18:33:38 |
| emily | also, Randy is going to be unavailable starting ~10 days from now, so we should get to any issues ASAP. | 18:34:06 |
| vcunat | Rushing big features late. That's a tension before all NixOS stable releases. | 18:37:41 |
| emily | indeed | 18:42:05 |
| emily | in this case, it's not so much a feature as a vital refactor | 18:42:18 |
| emily | Darwin support desperately needs it to be viable; we rushed the 12.3 SDK as an interim measure and we've already had major packages (QEMU, Qt) be unable to be updated without it | 18:42:41 |
| emily | those two projects don't support 12 officially, so we could easily end up in trouble within 6 months even doing security updates | 18:43:19 |
