| 25 Aug 2024 |
 flare | In reply to @vampyr3:matrix.org
wow , seeing as those have the same interface , that's definitely a manufacturer concern. I will look more into the ISO's around it , as you would think there would be some standardization around it you know. The thing is that ISO 7816 is essentially a full contact smart card specification stack.
For example what I have gathered is that ISO 7816-4 describes the pin interface and a lot of cards are compliant with this standard | 16:52:56 |
| flare | however 7816-15 describes how the internal data structure of the smartcard is to be laid out and access.
I havent read into this specific part too much as to whether specifically defines crypto tokens but either way it describes a file like data structure on smart cards
However no smart card has to follow BOTH. Memory cards are Just EEPROMs that connect to the contact interface specified in 7816-4. But dont provide any crypto circuity. So, not useful as a token.
| 16:56:22 |
| flare | so to have a smart card for crypto purposes you need to have a 7816-4 smart card with 7816-15 OR* pkcs#15 (crypto specific file system spec for smart card tokens).
All fine and dandy. apparently its impossible to find those cards that provide full pkcs#15 compliance so that they can be programmed by opensc. You usually find cards that only impliment partially pkcs#15 and the rest of how data is stored is left up to the manufacturer.
This is because FIPS 201 and SP 800-73 (US Government standards for ID smart card crypto tokens) Leave the internal data structure of the smart cards up to the manufacturuers
| 17:01:35 |
| flare | so in conclusion | 17:01:43 |
| flare | its one hell of a muddled mess. and If you want the exact same solution that is easy and nice to use. Get a yubikey | 17:02:16 |
| flare | Fun fact: You debit or credit card is also a smart card that follows these standards as a crypto token. Just its own decades long mess there | 17:03:21 |
| flare | * Fun fact: Your debit or credit card is also a smart card that follows these standards as a crypto token. Just its own decades long mess there | 17:03:29 |
| flare | * Fun fact: Your debit or credit card is also a smart card if it has a chip and that follows these standards as a crypto token. Just its own decades long mess there | 17:03:59 |
| flare | * its one hell of a muddled mess. and If you want the exact same solution that is easy and nice to use. *Get a yubikey instead* | 17:04:32 |
| flare | * its one hell of a muddled mess. and If you want the exact same solution that is easy and nice to use. **Get a yubikey instead** | 17:04:44 |
| flare | For me in the US I had a hell of a time finding a card that is fully compliant with these open standards and avoids vendor lock in. However for those in Europe there is hope
https://webservices.aventra.fi/webshop/index.php?route=product/category&path=60
Here you can get iso 7816 form factor smart cards that are fully compliant with open standard pkcs#15. Which means there is no need for proprietary software managed on windows.
a beautiful thing. Just for each card for me postage would make one card cost me $70. So not so great for me. Possible good for yall in europe | 17:09:06 |
| flare | * For me in the US I had a hell of a time finding a card that is fully compliant with these open standards and avoids vendor lock in. However for those in Europe there is hope
https://webservices.aventra.fi/webshop/index.php?route=product/category&path=60
Here you can get iso 7816 form factor smart cards that are fully compliant with open standard pkcs#15. Which means there is no need for proprietary software managed on windows.
a beautiful thing. Just for me postage would make one card cost me $70. So not so great for me. Possibly good for y'all in europe | 17:09:49 |
|  @superflyjohnson1:matrix.org joined the room. | 19:54:20 |
|  mindstorms6 joined the room. | 20:30:51 |
| 26 Aug 2024 |
|  von.dev joined the room. | 16:31:19 |
|  Ruther joined the room. | 19:05:16 |
| 27 Aug 2024 |
|  @jappie3:matrix.org joined the room. | 08:45:25 |
|  oliver.falvai joined the room. | 10:52:18 |
|  duckunix joined the room. | 15:03:34 |
|  libert.ador joined the room. | 21:56:18 |
| 28 Aug 2024 |
|  armeen joined the room. | 03:31:43 |
| 29 Aug 2024 |
|  @florens:matrix.org joined the room. | 12:21:22 |
| @florens:matrix.org left the room. | 12:21:37 |
| 30 Aug 2024 |
|  spd joined the room. | 15:55:58 |
|  firestz joined the room. | 20:28:40 |
| 31 Aug 2024 |
|  @shymega:one.ems.host left the room. | 07:43:39 |
|  tombl joined the room. | 08:27:00 |
|  tyx joined the room. | 08:48:14 |
|  voxxit joined the room. | 14:38:55 |
|  aaron joined the room. | 17:07:42 |
