| 18 Jun 2023 |
|  @tzycce:matrix.org left the room. | 12:55:14 |
| 21 Jun 2023 |
|  @alx_sim:matrix.org joined the room. | 19:42:51 |
| 25 Jun 2023 |
|  kadawee joined the room. | 15:35:37 |
| 29 Jun 2023 |
|  @futaki:matrix.org joined the room. | 01:29:40 |
| 1 Jul 2023 |
|  @lotte:chir.rs changed their profile picture. | 09:48:53 |
|  Airpods joined the room. | 18:16:32 |
| 4 Jul 2023 |
|  Galactus joined the room. | 06:47:12 |
| 5 Jul 2023 |
| Galactus changed their profile picture. | 13:26:00 |
|  trexd joined the room. | 15:12:23 |
| trexd | Is this a good room to discuss the current state of the flax package in nixpkgs? | 15:12:54 |
 Carl Thomé | In reply to @trexd:matrix.org
Is this a good room to discuss the current state of the flax package in nixpkgs? Yes | 18:34:00 |
| 6 Jul 2023 |
| trexd | Well currently updating flax is marked as broken on nixpkgs because it requires orbax to be built. I've started packaging orbax; however it requires a newer version of Jax than what is currently available on nixpkgs. Seems like people are working on it over here https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/pull/227145 but it's stalled because of the changes breaking a lot of packages. I was wondering what the best way to insert myself in this process to help out in getting an update to jax merged so I can fix the state of the flax pacakge. | 15:51:50 |
| Carl Thomé | From my side I just kinda went "damnit I'll stick to PyTorch then" but that feels a bit sad | 16:48:14 |
|  John Pertoft joined the room. | 20:01:46 |
| 7 Jul 2023 |
| trexd | I need flax to implement a small transformer model. Jax is easier to reason about for me as well | 01:37:32 |
| @lotte:chir.rs changed their profile picture. | 05:28:04 |
| 8 Jul 2023 |
|  ascendo joined the room. | 12:29:09 |
| 9 Jul 2023 |
|  Bruno Rodrigues joined the room. | 14:54:58 |
| 10 Jul 2023 |
| Bruno Rodrigues | Hi all, I’m Bruno and am interested in Nix to set up reproducible development environments for R (my main language, but am curious for any language whatsoever). I’m thinking about Nix to essentially replace {renv} + Docker (and maybe even {targets}) | 10:19:22 |
| Bruno Rodrigues | for now I’m reading the Nix pills and trying some things out | 10:19:34 |
 Gaétan Lepage | In reply to @trexd:matrix.org
Well currently updating flax is marked as broken on nixpkgs because it requires orbax to be built. I've started packaging orbax; however it requires a newer version of Jax than what is currently available on nixpkgs. Seems like people are working on it over here https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/pull/227145 but it's stalled because of the changes breaking a lot of packages. I was wondering what the best way to insert myself in this process to help out in getting an update to jax merged so I can fix the state of the flax pacakge. Hi ! I'm the dumb guy at the origin of this PR.
Indeed, we are struggling hard to get this through. A lot of problems have been tackled already. First and foremost, all of the packages (jax, jaxlib, jaxlibWithCuda) build fine now.
However, a few existing packages are broken by this update.
There are only 2: numpyro and tensorflow-datasets. | 13:18:52 |
| Gaétan Lepage | I am only targetting 0.4.12 with this PR because 0.4.13 brings yet new issues (related to jax's dependencies) | 13:19:34 |
| Gaétan Lepage | Honestly, it is kind of a nightmare ^^ | 13:19:49 |
| trexd | Yeah it seems like it. Ya'll are doing excellent work though :D | 17:45:14 |
 peddie | welcome! I've had some luck (with jbedo's help) setting up R development environments with flakes in the past year. feel free to ping me about it; I think nix is underused in the R world! | 22:11:53 |
| 11 Jul 2023 |
| Bruno Rodrigues | thanks peddie! actually I was exactly going to be asking this: should I use flakes for this? and another question: have you written down some of this into a guide ? | 05:31:26 |
 jbedo | the decision to use flakes is orthogonal to R, i use it and find it useful but it does have limitiations and are somewhat controversial | 05:39:21 |
| jbedo | regardless of using flakes or not, focusing on understanding core nix will go a long way | 05:43:30 |
| peddie | I've not written much down as it's just what I have managed to scrape together, and I don't have any blog or commit bits to nixpkgs. but there are examples in projects on github, like https://github.com/peddie/solar-api/blob/master/flake.nix | 05:55:52 |
| peddie | as to whether you should use flakes: not really sure, I just happened to go that route | 05:56:25 |
