| 5 Jun 2025 |
 emily | when you say "Linux control plane" though, are we talking mainline? because it seems these Celestica things are Broadcom, and my understanding was that the Broadcom switch stuff was basically totally useless on mainline without a pile of proprietary blobs. | 13:31:52 |
 raitobezarius | i think SN2700 can be sniped for 400 to 500 bucks in some cases fwiw | 13:34:34 |
| raitobezarius | but may still be too high above 120 USD I guess | 13:34:41 |
 Tom | Power Consumption is probably also slightly different between both of those options 😅 | 13:37:14 |
| raitobezarius | yeah and transreceivers are not in the same price range as well | 13:37:52 |
| raitobezarius | especially if you want to do long range | 13:37:56 |
| raitobezarius | same for NICs, etc. | 13:38:01 |
| emily | I thought those things had 10 Gbit/s ports? maybe I was imagining that. | 13:38:27 |
| raitobezarius | SN2700 is 32x100G | 13:38:42 |
| raitobezarius | the aliexpress thing yes | 13:38:49 |
| emily | but yeah as fun as it would be to play with it doesn't really serve the home use-case so much | 13:38:49 |
| raitobezarius | maybe SN2010 has 10G | 13:38:53 |
| * raitobezarius looks at his home | 13:39:12 |
| raitobezarius | yeah i guess | 13:39:13 |
 Mr. Defenestrator | Yea I saw '<5k' and thought typical prosumer stuff. Some ubiquiti home networks hit above that price range lmao | 13:39:49 |
| Mr. Defenestrator | Yea the mlxsw supported switches start at 25Gbe I think, its a more recent ASIC, so that also explains the price. | 13:40:28 |
| emily | well I'm open to being memed into buying something horrendously excessive but beyond three digits is a fairly hard sell :P | 13:42:06 |
| emily | I'd be up for Ubiquiti-level prices if it means mainline Linux / no blobs | 13:42:44 |
| Mr. Defenestrator | In reply to @emilazy:matrix.org
when you say "Linux control plane" though, are we talking mainline? because it seems these Celestica things are Broadcom, and my understanding was that the Broadcom switch stuff was basically totally useless on mainline without a pile of proprietary blobs. Yea a recent kernel at least. But it will need blobs, of course | 13:44:33 |
| Mr. Defenestrator | In reply to @raitobezarius:matrix.org
yeah and transreceivers are not in the same price range as well It's more about the fiber tbh. I have dozens of 40G transceivers that all require MPO. Bought for $4/ea. Any cable will cost $50 minimum. The CWDM optics are just hard to find. | 13:46:01 |
| raitobezarius | i have the opposite problem | 13:46:39 |
| raitobezarius | i have stupid amount of CWDM 100G optics almost for free | 13:46:46 |
| raitobezarius | but long range is not cheap | 13:47:11 |
 hexa | uhh, I think we tried one out in 2018 | 13:49:24 |
| hexa | sn2100 possibly? 🤔 | 13:49:55 |
| emily | right. I think both the cheapo Realtek stuff and mlxsw at least don't need userspace blobs | 13:50:03 |
| emily | AIUI from reading LKML posts, the Broadcom switch situation is that there's an "upstream" driver that basically just acts as a very dumb pipe between proprietary userspace tools and the switch ASIC | 13:50:24 |
| emily | so it's not quite what I'd consider a native Linux networking experience | 13:50:40 |
| hexa | or more like an sn2010 | 13:50:47 |
| hexa | so not exactly new, but still not worth abandoning 🙂 | 13:51:37 |
