In reply to @pyrox:pyrox.dev

has there been any work on the libre/binary-free bootstrap recently? Came across that discussion and at least to me doesn't seem like there's any movement on it

And if there isn't, would there be interest in me picking up that work? I've been looking at reducing nixpkgs' reliance on binary bootstraps in various places and openjdk/JDKs in general seem like a good place to do that for

Not really, at least to my knowledge.

I was the one who personally removed the previous bootstrap chain, because it was broken, unmaintained, and not even used.

If you want to look into it, be my guest, but you'll need to commit to maintaining it. I don't want to need to come back down the line and delete another bootstrap chain

In reply to @infinidoge:inx.moe

Not really, at least to my knowledge.

I was the one who personally removed the previous bootstrap chain, because it was broken, unmaintained, and not even used.

If you want to look into it, be my guest, but you'll need to commit to maintaining it. I don't want to need to come back down the line and delete another bootstrap chain

In reply to @msgilligan:matrix.org

I would personally love to see this, but I think it is not feasible at present. The limited bandwidth of current NixOS JVM contributors would be better spent elsewhere IMO.

If you are interested in using or contributing to a libre/binary-free JDK bootstrap, GUIX is the place. GUIX (last I checked) is lagging behind on Maven support (for example) so they could use help, too.

If someone wants to work to make the JDK toolchain binary free, the place to start might be with Maven. It is currently:

    sourceProvenance = with lib.sourceTypes; [
      binaryBytecode
      binaryNativeCode
    ];

If someone wants to work towards making the JDK toolchain binary free, a place to contribute might be with Maven. It is currently:

    sourceProvenance = with lib.sourceTypes; [
      binaryBytecode
      binaryNativeCode
    ];