| 27 Sep 2023 |
 infinisil | In reply to @poweruser64:matrix.org
After RFC 140 is in full effect, will packages still have categories of some sort? It seems like it would be a waste to get rid of all the work that has been done to classify 80000+ packages. Personally, I learn about a lot of software just by looking at what other packages are in the categories I use the most. We can always get that back from the commit history, though new packages won't have that anymore yeah | 09:44:43 |
| infinisil | The benefit of those categories is imo less significant that the benefit of improving the all-packages situation | 09:45:59 |
| infinisil | But it's great to have more feedback from people about relying on those categories for the other RFC, as you can see it discusses whethere a categorisation is worth having even :) | 09:46:57 |
 PowerUser64 | I'm still a little unsure, what's the real problem with all-packages? It's big, but it seems to not be a problem for the most part? | 09:48:07 |
 @piegames:matrix.org | I personally just don't want to care about which categories my packages belong into. If we delegate this to a team or something then I'm fine with it | 09:48:16 |
 K900 | It's also hard to keep organized | 09:48:18 |
| K900 | And categories are hard to choose "correctly" | 09:48:28 |
| K900 | So they're all over the place | 09:48:32 |
| @piegames:matrix.org | In reply to @poweruser64:matrix.org
I'm still a little unsure, what's the real problem with all-packages? It's big, but it seems to not be a problem for the most part? Infinisil had an entire talk about this on NixCon, recommend that | 09:48:38 |
| K900 | Also Github chokes on all-packages.nix changes half the time | 09:48:40 |
| @piegames:matrix.org | TL;DR: it *is* that bad | 09:48:56 |
| infinisil | Talk here | 09:49:58 |
| PowerUser64 | The talk was very good! It's actually what made me aware of all this | 09:51:06 |
| PowerUser64 | I'm definitely going to miss having all the audio packages in the same folder when this is implemented | 09:52:47 |
| infinisil | Want to help with the categorisation rfc to have a replacement? :D | 09:53:32 |
| PowerUser64 | I'd love to! | 09:53:54 |
| PowerUser64 | I have no idea how to help or what help is needed | 09:54:03 |
| infinisil | Really just review and participate in the discussion, it's all happening in the rfc comments for now | 09:54:47 |
| PowerUser64 | cool | 09:55:06 |
| PowerUser64 | I'll go read what they're all saying | 09:55:24 |
| K900 | "All the audio packages" | 09:55:41 |
| * K900 remembers Pipewire is still in development/libraries | 09:55:47 |
| PowerUser64 | Okayyy it's not perfect, but it doesn't need to be perfect to do its job well | 09:56:19 |
| PowerUser64 | it doesn't really matter where the packages are at the end of the day as long as there aren't two folders with the same name in the same directory | 09:57:22 |
