| 10 Mar 2026 |
 magic_rb | i would say that the code should be illegal, since its derived from everyones code without anyones permission | 16:41:03 |
| magic_rb | or assuming it was only derived from GPL code (unlikely) then it under the GPL and the copyright is held by everyone | 16:41:36 |
 jaen | YMMV, but in my view all of this is a capitalism problem, not a model problem. Eat the rich and suddenly models stop being immoral. And YMMV, but 3. is good actually. It's copyright that is immoral and EU having an internal legal report saying that LLM code without enough human input to qualify as transformative is in public domain. | 16:41:49 |
| magic_rb | no copyright is not immoral as long as copyright exists | 16:42:19 |
| magic_rb | i would prefer if there was no copyright, or rather everything was required to be under the AGPLv3 | 16:42:39 |
| magic_rb | but we dont live in that world, as such it is morally acceptable for me to enforce AGPLv3 for my projects so that they can't be profited of. Either everyone plays by the rules of no copyright or im not playing either | 16:43:22 |
| jaen | Fair I suppose? Before it gets further off the rails, just one remark that my understanding is according to this interpretation they can't really profit off such code, because it's not theirs to begin with, because without the transformative element it defaults to public domain. Of course another question is enforcing that by suing and winning, but it's the same problem with GPL in principle? | 16:46:04 |
| magic_rb | yeah i guess we agree mostly, and yes, not the right room for this at all, i just cant help myself. I have a very strong opinion on this issue | 16:47:38 |
| jaen | Yeah. We probably don't agree at the core (I don't really hate models), but we probably agree on hating people using them to the detriment of society at large. And it's understandable how a person with human feelings and empathy can get angry at that. Anyway, peace & out on this end | 16:51:54 |
| magic_rb | last remark:
(I don't really hate models)
if someone presents me a model which was trained only on code which is either all permissive or if GPL then produces GPL code, id consider it. ofc then the question of elecricity cost and training cost comes along and the fact that such a model would be incredibly useless. currently the tech fundamentally relies on theft to function
| 16:54:28 |
| magic_rb | * last remark:
(I don't really hate models)
if someone presents me a model which was trained only on code which is either all permissive or if GPL then produces GPL code, id consider it. ofc then the question of elecricity cost and training cost comes along and the fact that such a model would be incredibly useless. currently the tech fundamentally relies on theft to function | 16:54:33 |
| 24 May 2021 |
|  @grahamc:nixos.org set the history visibility to "world_readable". | 16:44:23 |
| @grahamc:nixos.org changed the room name to "" from "". | 16:44:23 |
|  Server Stats Discoverer (traveler bot) joined the room. | 16:44:33 |
| @grahamc:nixos.org invited  danielrf. | 16:44:48 |
| @grahamc:nixos.orgchanged room power levels. | 16:44:52 |
|  hexa joined the room. | 16:45:03 |
|  ajs124 joined the room. | 16:51:31 |
|  andi- joined the room. | 16:55:26 |
|  Matrix Traveler (bot) joined the room. | 16:58:08 |
|  hmenke joined the room. | 17:08:01 |
|  philipp joined the room. | 17:37:33 |
| danielrf joined the room. | 17:48:31 |
|  [0x4A6F] joined the room. | 18:46:31 |
|  samueldr joined the room. | 18:58:30 |
| samueldr left the room. | 19:03:27 |
| samueldr joined the room. | 19:03:48 |
| danielrf set the room topic to "Build Android (AOSP) using Nix || https://github.com/danielfullmer/robotnix". | 19:41:00 |
|  colemickens 🏳️🌈 joined the room. | 20:00:42 |
| 25 May 2021 |
|  rajivr joined the room. | 01:12:25 |
