| 22 Nov 2021 |
 @abathur:matrix.org | and there's a little more context to bring to bear when someone decides to talk to them about it | 23:35:40 |
 @piegames:matrix.org | In reply to @abathur:matrix.org
in this narrow context I guess I just mean that the problem with "just block them" isn't that you shouldn't just block them; it's that the community could in theory benefit from having a log that says a dozen contributors have blocked X for Y I think we do have this, at least for Discourse. But I generally agree. | 23:35:53 |
 @ryblade:matrix.org | In reply to @abathur:matrix.org
in this narrow context I guess I just mean that the problem with "just block them" isn't that you shouldn't just block them; it's that the community could in theory benefit from having a log that says a dozen contributors have blocked X for Y oh no no no no, hard disagree. that sounds almost like a pillory to me. | 23:36:04 |
| *  joepie91 🏳️🌈 would like to remind everybody of the concept of the "missing stair" | 23:36:47 |
| @abathur:matrix.org | maybe soften that and ask a curious question instead of slam the door | 23:36:48 |
| @ryblade:matrix.org | besides, i tend to agree with a lot of people that others find offensive, people like me would just invert that list to find friends :D | 23:36:52 |
| @ryblade:matrix.org | find the people with the most dislikes and say what's up | 23:37:04 |
| @ryblade:matrix.org | my block lists are PRIVATE, i absolutely refuse to participate in any system that even so much as anonymously add those in my blocklist to a public database. there's far too much room for expanding the scope of such a thing for bigger and bigger privacy abuses. | 23:38:49 |
| @ryblade:matrix.org | * my block lists are PRIVATE, i absolutely refuse to participate in any system that even so much as anonymously adds those in my blocklist to a public database. there's far too much room for expanding the scope of such a thing for bigger and bigger privacy abuses. | 23:39:08 |
| @abathur:matrix.org | (note, I didn't say that it should be public; you've projected that) | 23:39:57 |
 Irenes | I agree with ryblade here | 23:40:10 |
| @abathur:matrix.org | anyways; dinner | 23:40:11 |
| Irenes | mechanisms like that are cute for what they accomplish but the cost of tying it to private blocks is too great | 23:40:26 |
| Irenes | in that it makes private blocks into something.... else | 23:40:32 |
| Irenes | I've seen people legitimately feel brigaded by too many emoji reacts | 23:40:54 |
| Irenes | this would be way worse in that you can't take the action to protect yourself without it sending a public social signal | 23:41:09 |
| @abathur:matrix.org | I'll be on mobile maybe | 23:41:12 |
| Irenes | hm | 23:41:41 |
| Irenes | interesting thought about the log being private I guess | 23:41:48 |
| Irenes | like visible only to moderators maybe? | 23:41:53 |
| Irenes | I don't think that would be right for this proposal, because we're trying to minimize the extent to which the community team's formal power places them above the rest of the community | 23:42:17 |
| Irenes | like there's a need for there to be some or this wouldn't work because bad actors would refuse to engage with it | 23:42:31 |
| Irenes | but we want it to be just the essential elements | 23:42:39 |
| Irenes | but it could well be the right idea for a different community, with different goals | 23:42:53 |
| @ryblade:matrix.org | In reply to @abathur:matrix.org
(note, I didn't say that it should be public; you've projected that) excuse me, please cool it with the accusations, okay? "having a log that says a dozen contributors have blocked X for Y" is what you said, you were never clear about who would see this log. since we are discussing this in the context of an open source project, it was only natural that i assumed some transparency would be involved. furthermore, i still refuse to upload any data to even a private team of moderators whenever i block a person. that. is. PRIVATE. | 23:42:55 |
| Irenes | yeah I think it was a natural way to understand the thing, fwiw, and I also read it that way at first | 23:44:03 |
| @abathur:matrix.org | You have the power to ask if I meant a private or public log | 23:46:55 |
| @ryblade:matrix.org | i also have the power to not CONSENT to such a system in the first place, public or private. | 23:47:50 |
| @abathur:matrix.org | Sure | 23:48:07 |
| @ryblade:matrix.org | and please refrain from demeaning me, i've already asked this once already | 23:48:37 |
