Nix + dotnet - Public Room Timeline

	Nix + dotnet	121 Members
		24 Servers

Load older messages

Sender	Message	Time
14 Aug 2023
mdarocha	but i guess all the blazor stuff isn’t there, so it has to be added	07:50:19
Yarek T	Hmm, with dotnet you usually specify all the dependencies in its <foo>.csproj file, and they get pulled down in a restore step. Does Nix replace that somehow?	16:39:14
Yarek T	I suppose it wants to if it needs reproducible builds	16:39:25
Yarek T	Oh, are you using `dotnetCorePackages.sdk_7_0` or `pkgs.dotnet-sdk_7` ? because the former doesn't package `aspnetcore` even though it says it should	16:41:49
Yarek T	Oh wait, isn't mono like completely gone from dotnet these days? Hmm. Is this thing open source? Do you have something I can replicate on my machine?	16:46:26
mdarocha	dotnet-sdk_7 is an alias to dotnetcorePackages.sdk_7_0, so I don't know how you can encounter differences between the two	16:51:04
mdarocha	they both point to a packaged sdk, which should contain the aspnetcore framework files	16:51:23
mdarocha	In reply to @yarekt:matrix.org Hmm, with dotnet you usually specify all the dependencies in its <foo>.csproj file, and they get pulled down in a restore step. Does Nix replace that somehow? in case of Nix, it runs dotnet restore and then builds a deps.nix based on the restored nugets. This doesnt always work, cause sometimes (ie. in case of alternative sdk packages) not all nugets are pulled at restore	16:52:24
mdarocha	but most framework and SDK stuff is included by default when using buildDotnetModule, so it isn't usually a problem	16:52:53
mdarocha	the error like with blazor is mostly probably due to missing stuff in the dependencies included by default, which aren't also properly picked up into deps.nix	16:53:40
mdarocha	unless there's some other problems, it would also help with debugging to share a repo with a reproduction of the problems	16:54:19
mdarocha	* unless there's some other problems, it would also help with debugging to share a repo with a reproduction of the errors	16:54:24
Emma [it/its]	In reply to @yarekt:matrix.org Oh wait, isn't mono like completely gone from dotnet these days? Hmm. Is this thing open source? Do you have something I can replicate on my machine? my thing? yes	17:47:15
Emma [it/its]	`git clone --recursive https://git.rory.gay/matrix/MatrixRoomUtils.git`	17:48:08
Emma [it/its]	build with `nix build '.?submodules=1#web' -L`	17:48:26
Emma [it/its]	though if you want i can set up a quick and dirty repro repo (just the template project with a flake)	17:50:02
Emma [it/its]	keep in mind that repo has the missing framework package manually added	17:52:28
Emma [it/its]	In reply to @magikarpz:matrix.org follow the docs to get a buildDotnetModule derivation working, and then run the fetch-deps script from the derivation attributes, as shown in the docs ah i remember now why i cant use fetch-deps	17:57:23
Emma [it/its]	`error: getting status of '/home/root@Rory/EmptyBlazorWasmApp/default.nix': No such file or directory` that doesnt appear to work with flakes	17:57:37
Emma [it/its]	building `.#default.passthru.fetch-deps` made a shellscript as result, i guess thats normal?	19:31:50
Emma [it/its]	oh, using that did include browser-wasm	19:33:13
Emma [it/its]	still fails to build though: `emptyblazorwasmapp-v1> /nix/store/igwf7hm6cjdcl0mac0n2rpmq47ssil6k-dotnet-sdk-7.0.306/sdk/7.0.306/Sdks/Microsoft.NET.Sdk/targets/Microsoft.NET.Sdk.FrameworkReferenceResolution.targets(135,5): error NETSDK1084: There is no application host available for the specified RuntimeIdentifier 'browser-wasm'. [/build/ml30php8kkq4lqgh2yc0g9fma5c2jnpm-source/EmptyBlazorWasmApp/EmptyBlazorWasmApp.csproj]`	19:35:29
Emma [it/its]	Download EmptyBlazorWasmApp.tar.xz	19:36:35
Emma [it/its]	steps taken: create empty blazor wasm project add simple flake with 1 output generate a deps.nix by invoking a slightly modified version of nuget-to-nix with a wrapper script (mkdeps) that dotnet restore's to a folder for nuget-to-nix to operate on use `nix build .\#default.passthru.fetch-deps` to generate script at `result` run ./result copy output file over deps.nix run `nix build .#`	19:38:45
15 Aug 2023
raphi	In reply to @emma:rory.gay steps taken: create empty blazor wasm project add simple flake with 1 output generate a deps.nix by invoking a slightly modified version of nuget-to-nix with a wrapper script (mkdeps) that dotnet restore's to a folder for nuget-to-nix to operate on use `nix build .\#default.passthru.fetch-deps` to generate script at `result` run ./result copy output file over deps.nix run `nix build .#` as a workaround you can set `useAppHost = false` and `selfContainedBuild = true` in the buildDotnetModule call blazor wasm support is not ideal atm	08:27:06
Yarek T	In reply to @emma:rory.gay steps taken: create empty blazor wasm project add simple flake with 1 output generate a deps.nix by invoking a slightly modified version of nuget-to-nix with a wrapper script (mkdeps) that dotnet restore's to a folder for nuget-to-nix to operate on use `nix build .\#default.passthru.fetch-deps` to generate script at `result` run ./result copy output file over deps.nix run `nix build .#` Deps generated are the same for me	16:40:15
Yarek T	Ah but yes, I get the error. How strange. I will poke around more.	16:45:53
	nevoyu left the room.	19:34:14
Emma [it/its]	In reply to @emma:rory.gay steps taken: create empty blazor wasm project add simple flake with 1 output generate a deps.nix by invoking a slightly modified version of nuget-to-nix with a wrapper script (mkdeps) that dotnet restore's to a folder for nuget-to-nix to operate on use `nix build .\#default.passthru.fetch-deps` to generate script at `result` run ./result copy output file over deps.nix run `nix build .#` the fetch-deps script added one that was missing before with the nuget-to-nix script (Microsoft.NETCore.App.Runtime.Mono.browser-wasm)	19:56:31
Emma [it/its]	or at least, it did in our project, didnt check in the repro	19:57:49

Show newer messages

Back to Room ListRoom Version: 9