| 26 May 2024 |
 nat-418 | I don't think people need to be told that they can search the word "nixos" on SO or lookup a hashtag. I don't see any value-add | 09:14:27 |
| nat-418 | * I don't think people need to be told that they can search the word "nixos" on SO or lookup a hashtag on X . I don't see any value-add | 09:14:41 |
| nat-418 | I am planning to add back some of the "unofficial" stuff later but I need to take my kid to the playground | 09:15:14 |
| nat-418 | I basically un-drafted the PR so I could get feedback | 09:15:32 |
 avocadoom | In reply to @nat418:matrix.org
I don't think people need to be told that they can search the word "nixos" on SO or lookup a hashtag on X . I don't see any value-add The issue suggested maybe switching the hashtags for the Nixos profiles | 09:24:39 |
 garbas | In reply to @avocadoom:avocadoom.de
So removing Reddit is a thing that was mostly agreed on, Discord was discussed but not really agreed on, but why did you remove Mastodon, Twitter and stack overflow? The discussion came up with a better solution there Reddit links stays as do other unofficial links. We will mark them as unofficial. | 09:56:43 |
| garbas | * Reddit links stays as do other unofficial links. We will mark them as unofficial and make it obvious what is moderated and what is not. | 09:57:19 |
| garbas | A community in the eyes of marketing is different what community is in the eyes of moderation. We need to show and will where different parts of the community are. There are definitely problems with nixos reddit, but if anybody thinks unlinking them from nixos org will solve the problem they are wrong. We have already more than half a year of evidence to support this. Unlinking to nixos reddit should not be the first step and right now new users receive more support there than anywhere else. Especially for those who are regulars on that platform. | 10:02:40 |
 @qyliss:fairydust.space | I've never heard of a marketing team before that doesn't care at all about brand image in the way that this one seems not to. Usually marketers are very careful about what gets associated with their brand. | 10:05:40 |
| avocadoom | I personally cannot accept the accusation that I am not making an effort to improve the image of the board... This is just a brutally heated discussion and getting everyone to a conclusion is just not that easy | 10:34:35 |
| @qyliss:fairydust.space | Sorry, that's not what I meant. | 10:35:03 |
| avocadoom | * I personally cannot accept the accusation that I am not making an effort to improve the image of the brand... This is just a brutally heated discussion and getting everyone to a conclusion is just not that easy | 10:35:30 |
| @qyliss:fairydust.space | What I meant was that definitive statements like locking the issue, definitively saying "Reddit links stays" when that doesn't even seem to be consensus among members of the team, etc. create this impression of the team. I did not mean that I think this is what the members of the team actually personally think. | 10:39:03 |
| @qyliss:fairydust.space | (and I wanted to bring up long-term brand image because I haven't seen it given much focus in discussion so far) | 10:45:14 |
 djacu | These ad hominem are not helpful, and only hurt members of the marketing team and sow division into the greater community.
The subreddit has 25k members and many people feel welcome, receive help, and bring up the next generation of users. The same is true of the discord. People find their own space that fits them best. I don't think we should remove links to those communities because of a handful of bad actors.
If you have issue with a post or user of one of those spaces, go message the moderators of that space. | 15:25:02 |
 hexa | But that is precisely the issue, reddit is essentially unmoderated terrain. | 15:29:15 |
| hexa | * But that is precisely the issue, /r/nixos is essentially unmoderated terrain, so there is no recourse. | 15:29:31 |
| djacu | The moderators of r/nixos have removed posts when brought to their attention. | 15:32:26 |
 @janik0:matrix.org | In reply to @djacu:matrix.org
The moderators of r/nixos have removed posts when brought to their attention. It honestly doesn't seem like that, I can go onto r/nixos and easily find >10 posts/comments with anything from personal harassment to straight up hateful comments toward minorities. The only post that I'm aware that was removed was by a reddit auto-moderation action. | 15:43:57 |
| @janik0:matrix.org | And honestly, it is really bad that we are at a point where "just a few hateful comments here and there" just get's accepted like it's nothing. | 15:45:58 |
| @janik0:matrix.org | Like I'm personally at a point where I'm considering leaving NixOS and the (mostly) amazing community around it behind because I don't feel welcome anymore. Having to discuss something as trivial as this in such length just is saddening. | 15:48:17 |
| @janik0:matrix.org | * Like I'm personally at a point where I'm considering leaving NixOS and the (mostly) amazing community around it behind because I don't feel welcome anymore. Having to discuss something as trivial as this in such length is saddening. | 15:48:37 |
 infinisil | Suggestion: Link to a wiki article specifically for unofficial community spaces. This does require one more click to get to reddit and Discord, but it also allows other places to be easily added by anybody | 15:50:19 |
| djacu | In reply to @janik0:matrix.org
It honestly doesn't seem like that, I can go onto r/nixos and easily find >10 posts/comments with anything from personal harassment to straight up hateful comments toward minorities. The only post that I'm aware that was removed was by a reddit auto-moderation action. And did you report those posts/comments? We cannot know what is or is not being done without communicating with the mods of that space. | 15:51:20 |
| djacu | In reply to @janik0:matrix.org
And honestly, it is really bad that we are at a point where "just a few hateful comments here and there" just get's accepted like it's nothing. strawman | 15:51:28 |
| djacu | In reply to @infinisil:matrix.org
Suggestion: Link to a wiki article specifically for unofficial community spaces. This does require one more click to get to reddit and Discord, but it also allows other places to be easily added by anybody A link to the nixos subreddit was actually removed recently from the wiki.
https://wiki.nixos.org/w/index.php?title=Get_In_Touch&diff=prev&oldid=12699 | 15:52:27 |
| infinisil | Ah, I feel like this would be a good compromise though | 15:54:32 |
| hexa | The wiki is an official platform, and I reverted a change there that was made unilaterally, pointing to the the requirement to discuss this and sync with the decision for the homepage. | 15:59:58 |
| hexa | * | 16:00:35 |
| hexa | So making the wiki pages unofficial again when it runs under the nixos.org domain seems wrong | 16:01:27 |
